Was this a cover-up by the USMC or was it an accident read the story:Family raises questions about Marine’s death in Africa
Zoom
By GENE JOHNSON
Associated Press Writer
On the afternoon of March 23, two superiors took a 21-year-old Marine, Lance Cpl. Dustin Canham, into a tent at Camp Lemonier, a U.S. base in the rocky desert of the Horn of Africa.
Exactly what happened inside remains unclear, except this: Canham died.
In letters, the Marines told Canham’s family he collapsed while exercising. His father and his 19-year-old widow believe that’s half the story. They were told by Canham’s fellow Marines that he was being punished for accidentally chipping another Marine’s tooth. They suspect he might have dropped dead from being forced to work out too hard.
A military autopsy determined the manner of death to be "natural" and said Canham had a mildly enlarged heart. But the medical examiners were not told the circumstances of Canham’s death and thus did not consider heat exhaustion as a possible cause, The Associated Press has learned.
After the AP raised questions last week, Armed Forces Medical Examiner Craig T. Mallak and the deputy medical examiner who performed the autopsy, Cmdr. Timothy D. Monaghan, told the family they would take another look at Canham’s case.
"They try to make it sound routine, but there’s nothing routine about taking one Marine aside," said Canham’s widow, Devyn. "Why wouldn’t they be doing their daily exercises together?"
The AP has also learned that one of the two superiors who brought Canham into the tent, Sgt. Jesus Diaz, was reassigned out of the platoon following the death.
A spokeswoman at Marine Corps headquarters declined to comment, citing the continuing investigation, as did representatives of the Naval Criminal Investigative Service, which is conducting its own inquiry. The AP was unable to locate contact information for Diaz or the other superior, Cpl. Richard Abril.
Canham, 21, of Lake Stevens, had arrived at Camp Lemonier, in the African nation of Djibouti, about a week earlier. The U.S. maintains the 500-acre base for its Combined Joint Task Force-Horn of Africa, which blends traditional security and training roles with humanitarian efforts to combat terrorism.
Canham was assigned to the Marine Forces Reserve’s 6th Engineer Support Battalion, 4th Marine Logistics Group, out of Portland, Ore., but was primarily based at Fort Lewis. In Djibouti, he was serving with the 8th Provisional Security Company, installing and repairing fuel equipment.
None of his platoon mates would comment when contacted by the AP. But some did speak with Devyn, telling her that earlier in the day, Dustin was unloading a truck with other Marines when they began joking around and throwing rocks at each other. Dustin chipped another Marine’s tooth, she said.
Shortly before 4 p.m., Diaz and Abril brought Canham into a tent. Dustin soon collapsed; other Marines saw Diaz run out of the tent to get help, Devyn said. Resuscitation efforts failed. He was pronounced dead at the camp’s medical clinic at 5:12 p.m.
One letter to the family, written by Lt. Col. J.R. Hill of the 6th Engineer Support Battalion, said, "Dustin was in his air-conditioned quarters while exercising when he unexpectedly collapsed," and added that "the Marines who found him" immediately called for help.
Another, written by Lt. Col. Thomas E. Foos, commanding officer of 8th Provisional Security Company, and Capt. Craig E. Harris, commander of Alpha Company at Lemonier, said, "Dustin was exercising with his fire team leader in his tent doing what we call the Daily Seven" _ an exercise routine that includes push-ups and core-body work _ and that he collapsed after just two or three minutes.
None of the letters explained why Canham was in the tent with two superiors. Devyn Canham said three Marines told her it was not Dustin’s own tent, but another that might not have been air-conditioned. The high temperature that afternoon neared the mid-90s.
Dustin’s father, Mark Canham, said an investigator confirmed to him that Dustin was doing physical training in lieu of receiving a black mark on his record, typically referred to as a "page 11," when he died. Devyn said no military officials have told her that.
The nine-page autopsy report makes no mention of Canham exercising; it says merely that he collapsed while in his quarters. Canham’s heart weighed 450 grams, at the top of the normal range.
The medical examiner listed the cause of death as a thickening of the left ventricular wall, a condition sometimes found in endurance athletes. Canham was in excellent shape, his family said.
"His enlarged heart and hypertrophic left ventricular wall left him vulnerable to disruption of life-sustaining cardiac rhythms," Monaghan concluded.
Heat exhaustion can cause such a disruption.
Dr. Allen Burke, director of the Kernan Hospital Pathology Laboratory at the University of Maryland, provided a consultation for the autopsy. He agreed with the finding about Dustin’s heart condition, but said examination did "not disclose an anatomic cause of death."
Although Mark Canham signed a privacy waiver authorizing the military to discuss the autopsy with the AP, the military would not allow an interview with the pathologists. The AP instead gave its questions to Mark Canham, who asked them of Monaghan last week.
According to Mark Canham, Monaghan said that he was unaware Dustin had been exercising or that he was being punished when he died, and that he had no reason to suspect heat exhaustion or heat stroke. Mallak confirmed that, Devyn and her lawyer said.
Mark Canham has spent the past two months trying to contact his son’s friends in the Marines, investigators and members of Congress to pry loose any information he can.
"I just want to know what happened," he said. "I wish I could let the whole thing go. But that would be a grave injustice to my son."
(© 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)
More headlines…
Alleged B.C. gang leader pleads not guilty to drug smuggling
Nine people contract E. coli, possibly from lettuce
Tri-City residents save Kennewick fossil dig site
Budget crisis forces King County to slash law enforcement
Police arrest robbery suspect in West Seattle
Family raises questions about Marine’s death in Africa
State shuts down cranes in Seattle, Renton
Des Moines woman sentenced for husband’s murder
4 avoid felony convictions for Evergreen College violence
Feds say they will seek to detain Everett grifter
Photo Galleries
(3 photos) Orcas return to Sound with baby
Whale researchers in Friday Harbor say a pod of killer whales has returned from the ocean to Puget Sound waters with a new…
(15 photos) The day in photos: Thursday June 5th
A slideshow of the day’s images at home, across the country, and around the world.
(26 photos) Puget Sound low tides
Near-record low tides are attracting beachcombers to the shores of Puget Sound to poke into pools for exposed marine life…
(14 photos) The day in photos: Wednesday June 4th
A slideshow of the day’s images at home, across the country, and around the world.
(14 photos) The day in photos: Tuesday June 3rd
A slideshow of the day’s images at home, across the country, and around the world.
More photo galleries »
Home | Contact Us | Terms of Use | Privacy
It sounds like he was being punished–if true–physical training is not something that is routine when you are out of a training enviroment–but it is not unheard of–
It is possible this was happening–but it does not sound like it is anything more than that–It does not sound like murder–it sounds like an accident.
High school athletes die just like this –all the time.
They are working out and their heart gives out–because of some undiagnosed heart condition.
I feel sorry for the family but it does not sound like it was premeditated.
Recent Comments